| Author | 
         | 
         
      
        
         
         Francorosso Newbie 
          
 
  Joined: September 30 2017 Location: United States
 Online Status: Offline Posts: 7
          | 
        
         
          
           | Posted: October 11 2018 at 11:18 | IP Logged
		     | 
                    
            		  
           | 
           
          
           
  | 
           
          
Here's the situation: In my basement I have 3 Insteon 
 Switchlinc dimmers in different places, all to control 
 the overhead lights.  Only switch A is actually 
 connected to the load, switches B and C are connected to 
 line power.  I have set switches B and C as CONTROLLERS 
 of switch A.
 The question is whether switches B and C should also be 
 RESPONDERS to switch A.  I didn't think so but somehow 
 when I imported my links from Houselinc they show up as 
 responders as well as controllers.
  __________________ Frank
         | 
       
       
        | Back to Top | 
         
          
         | 
       
       
       
        |   | 
      
        
         
         TonyNo Moderator Group 
          
  
  Joined: December 05 2001 Location: United States
 Online Status: Offline Posts: 2889
          | 
        
         
          
           | Posted: October 11 2018 at 18:56 | IP Logged
		     | 
                    
            		  
           | 
           
          
           
  | 
           
          
I'd say no since B and C are not controlling anything.
         | 
       
       
        | Back to Top | 
         
          
          
         | 
       
       
       
        |   | 
      
        
         
         Frank-H Newbie 
          
  
  Joined: July 02 2018 Location: United States
 Online Status: Offline Posts: 3
          | 
        
         
          
           | Posted: October 22 2018 at 14:46 | IP Logged
		     | 
                    
            		  
           | 
           
          
           
  | 
           
          
If all three switches are to control one light and 
 switches B and C are not also responders to switch A:
 1. they will not reflect when you turn on the light 
 using switch A. 
 2. to turn off the light using a different switch than 
 A (the one you used to turn it on), you will have to 
 hit off on that switch twice, once to sync it to 
 switch A and once to actually tell A to turn it off.
 When you make them responders to A it will be switch A 
 that tells them to also show the light is on (in the 
 leds on the switch) when A does turn it on. Being 
 responders to A keeps them each in sync with A.
 BTW - They also should be responders to each other to 
 keep them in sync with each other. Then it doesn't 
 matter which switch tells A to turn on the light, any 
 of the switches will accurately tell A to turn off and 
 the leds on all three switches will all be in sync 
 with the actual state of the light.
 Needless to say, because it is directly connected to 
 the light, switch A's leds are always in sync with the 
 light.
  __________________ The Blind Squirrel-
 Even I find a nut once in a while.
         | 
       
       
        | Back to Top | 
         
          
         | 
       
       
       
        |   | 
      
        
         
         smarty Super User 
          
  
  Joined: May 21 2006 Location: United States
 Online Status: Offline Posts: 729
          | 
        
         
          
           | Posted: October 22 2018 at 15:10 | IP Logged
		     | 
                    
            		  
           | 
           
          
           
  | 
           
          
Nicely stated Frank-H.
 
 Welcome to the group!
  __________________ Elk - Insteon - BlueIris - DMC1 - PowerHome - XLobby - HA_Bridge w/Dots - Brultech
         | 
       
       
        | Back to Top | 
         
          
         | 
       
       
       
        |   |